Signed in as: Guest
| Login |
|
WTO forum
| |
| From: | PascalLamy | 12/16/2005 6:37 am |
| To: | ALL |
(1 of 27) | | | | 2120.1 | |
Conference mid-point, some small and volatile progress, and still too much to do.
Hi — and thank you to those of you who took the time to send comments on this diary. Great to know someone is reading this! I also got some interesting questions — hope to have the time to do an on-line chat next year. The sun is shining again in HK this morning — good omen for what will be another long day? We’re at the mid-point of the Conference and the path ahead can either become a slippery slope or a careful climb upward. I push, as I should, for the latter, but I also think we should now be asking ourselves: can we move 149 Members in the same direction? Listening to some of the Minister’s statements throughout the day I’m reminded of how many people in the world are watching us .... so many have a stake in the outcome of this Conference. This morning I feel more than ever the need for the work to begin in earnest.
Delegates from the 49 poorest countries are gathering to meet with me. I know they are expecting to hear what I and the other Members will do about the issues they care about. They are keen to get access to rich countries’ markets for their products — free of barriers. Some of them remind me that they represent only a tiny fraction of world trade, less than 1%, they cannot be seen as a threat to anyone — do they have any chance? I see my task as ensuring that their voices are heard and their points taken into account.
Straight to a big meeting with the African Group. More than 300 delegates. They are determined that nobody should forget that this is meant to be a development Round. In all these discussions we’re inching upward towards something concrete.... some words that we can put down on paper and begin to see a bit — a very little bit — of convergence. It’s a fascinating process, almost magical at times, but always excruciating for everyone involved .... especially when you rarely get any sleep. But I must confess that seeing just a sparkle of what could become a big light, a textual agreement, is worth every minute of hard work.
Next meeting: the delegation of Ukraine. The Minister makes it a point to tell me that membership of the WTO is his government’s top priority and that everything is being done so it can occur next year. New members coming to the WTO — Saudi Arabia officially joined the organization just before this conference, on December 11, bringing the total membership to 149. There are some 30 countries in the line-up for membership. Contradictions surface very clearly during these big events: while some out there are shouting “sink the WTO!”, others, notably poorer countries, are doing everything they can to get in.
A rare moment of ease during this tough day — I’m coming out of the pressure cooker for a few minutes to attend the signing ceremony for the accession of Tonga to the WTO..... a pretty joyous occasion for this island country of 112,000 people. Tonga, the “Friendy Island”, is a “milestone” country, positioned next to the international date line — and it has a milestone place in the WTO — it will become the organization’s 150th member. Mâloh y léléi!
Back to work, although it’s already dark, many people going out for dinner. Tough luck for me and Secretariat staff. We have to stay on and prepare for the difficult task of getting everyone to agree on mapping out areas of progress — however small. Back into the “fish-bowl” for tough negotiations. Long hours, desperately trying to make people focus, I’m not allowed a moment of distraction now. I feel calm nonetheless because I’m confident that what we’re shaping has come from the bottom up, from the Members, developed and developing, small island countries, from powers like US, EU, China, India and Brazil, and also from the group of the poorest countries, who are perhaps the most eloquent of all on why we must not fail. Different interests, a myriad of signals and signs to decipher, to make sense of, before stealing a little sleep. I’m reminded of a Chinese proverb: no wind, no waves. Something is happening. A demain!
PS. I hope I have some time to shop for Christmas presents when the Conference is over.
Edited 12/16/2005 7:13 am by PascalLamy |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.2 in reply to 2120.1 | |
Dear Mr. Lamy,
I have been trying to read your articles and lately your daily (diary) messages from the WTO Conference in Hong Kong.
The thing which strikes me very boldly is the sincerety, honesty and frankness in what you say. I myselfy could say this very openly. I feel you at least try to understand whole heartedly the situation the poor countries are in and what little they ask compared to the others who have the power. Please continue to do your best for all the parties in an equal and balanced way without ignoring the dire straits those are in who really need understanding and more importantly concrete steps towards contributing to improve their position. I have a gut feeling that you have guts to do it with your team. But on the other hand whatever you try to do might not be fruitful as the ones with real power could put obstacles in your front. This is another unfortunate fact of the global village (the world) we are living in it today !..
I sincerely wish you and your team all the best of luck and will you need in this global trade game.
Best regards,
SADIK BAYDERE, Mr. - Istanbul
|
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.3 in reply to 2120.1 | |
Dear Mr Lamy, I want to thank you for your commitment to bridging the gap in communication between the WTO and the people represented at that forum. Remember, we're far closer to mutual understanding and cooperation now than we were just 6 years ago when the complete lack of comprehension lead to the Seattle disaster. I'd like to quote Dr Earl Reum, Co-ordinator of studenst activities at Lakewood, Colorado. I think this message is relevant to all the participants in your conference: "I sincerely wish you will have the experience of thinking up a new idea, planning it, and following it to completion, then having it be magnificiently successful. I also hope you go through the same process and have something fail terribly. I wish you could know how it feels to run with all your heart and lose horribly. I wish that you could achieve some great good for [humanity] and have nobody know it except you. I wish you could find something so worthwile that you deem it worthy of devoting your life. I hope you become frustrated and dissatisfed enough to begin to push back the very barriers of your own personality limitations. I hope you make a stupid unethical mistake and get caught red handed and are big enough to say those magical words "I was wrong". I hope you give so much of yourself that some days you wonder if its worth it all. I wish for you a magnificent obsession that will give you a reason for living and purpose and direction and life. I wish for you the worst kind of criticism for everything you do because that makes you fight to achieve beyond what you normally would. I wish for you the experience of leadership." I wish you the best christmas. Dominic Meagher Student, Australian National University Director, AIESEC ACT |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.4 in reply to 2120.1 | |
Dear Mr LAMY, I've been reading your blog since the beginning of the week; it really is something interesting you decided to do to share these moments with us. It's also an honour to see how France is well represented in this organisation. I have followed, as much as I can, your work at the WTO, and really think you are the kind of person that could manage to give a better image from this organisation that has been, over the last years, seen and presented (unfairly) as the last demon on earth (after the USA, maybe). You know, it is sometimes really terrible to see how people look at the WTO, but moreover how journalists present it to the audience. I might be wrong, but I think that, among other reasons, it is seen as something that weakens states and their power. Maybe you experienced it also when you worked at the European Commision. Anyway, I wanted to tell you that I really admire the things you are trying to do, even if I don't always agree with all your proposals or decisions, and that I wish you to manage. Keep on, I think, as I know you do, that it is worth it, and that somehow the result will even be better than expected. Sincerely yours, Sébastien BRAHA |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.5 in reply to 2120.1 | |
Dear Mr. Lamy
It's a great pleasure to read your devoted diary notes from Hong Kong. I wish best luck and succes to you in your hard path of work at WTO.
Lasse Makela
Yichun, Heilongjiang Province
China |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.6 in reply to 2120.1 | |
Dear Mr. Lamy,
I have had the opportunity to watch you, with huge interest and even more huge curiosity, over the years of my country's accession process to the EU. Indeed I very much appreciated your personal touch and involment, your frank attitude (not always pleasant to hear the truth) and yet the welcoming meaning behind it, to the candidate countries for which the European dream and aspiration was acquiring a face, somebody who would listen and respond. Getting Ministers together, somewhere out of the huge Brussels establishment, was in my view very wise and very fruitful. Consequently, it is with enthusiasm (genuine) that I watched you become our DG in the WTO, although regretting to lose our Commissioner. But I had never imagined the "caliber" (fashionable word) of the performance which would follow. It is with a certain awe that I follow your activity and role in the events (pre and at Hong Kong). Maybe it is your marathon philosophy and training, maybe it is your French spirit, maybe the WTO finally received a blessing...
I will only mention some bribes of France Info on the opening day of the Ministerial: "...c'est au Français, Pascal Lamy, Directeur Géneral de l'OMC, de guider...; ...parviendra-t-il à sortir le cycle de l'impasse? ... mais ce marathonien aux yeux bleu acier est bien décidé ..."
Voilà, que vous dire d'autre que "bon courage" (expression bien française), et surtout "MERCI".
Anna Ashikali (Chypre)
Genève
|
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.7 in reply to 2120.1 | |
Another day left, but esperance is begining to jump up within the negotiations meetings on Honk Kong.
The target is now more near than before this conference.
Your team must continue their job and you too, because, Members (or delegates) need some insurance to take the good option for themselves and the world trade in general.
A big chance is offering to members in hong kong to make a minimal consensus. they are passing to side.
Good job and persevere more, your are approaching the goal.
Cordially Mr Adil DIANI
Ministery of foreign trade (Morocco)
asdil@yahoo.com / 0021264.79.04.83 |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.8 in reply to 2120.1 | |
|
2120.2 in reply to 2120.1 |
|
|
Dear Mr. Lamy,
First of all, welcome to Hong Kong. I hope you will love this city whether or not any solid agreement or result will be achieved by the end of the conference, and regardless the different voices within and outside HKCEC.
Did you have good exercise in HKCEC? Or I should ask if you managed to take good rest in the past few days.
Thank you so much for sharing your diary. It is much appreciated. I have been reading your diary since the begining of this week. I was in Grand Hall when you gave your speech at the opening ceremony. I witnessed the protests on streets. I heard the songs by NGOs.
The thing which strikes me is the sincerety and frankness in what you say, especially when you said the ones on the streets shouting "No No WTO" and the NGOs inside the building were also stakeholders of this conference. Yes, they are! I don't know how much WTO can do to narrow the differences among members. I atteneded Mr. Rockwell's briefing everyday and his most frequently used words are "differences", "complicated", and "complex issue".
At least you understand the situation the poor countries are in and you know too well how hard it is to ask the rich (or richer) countries to give way, for economical, political, or whatever reasons. Sometimes it is just all about guesture!
Please continue to do your best with your team for all members and all nations. It is not WTO posting the unfair taxes and tariffs. Please continue to provide a platform for fair and open negotiation. From which the world will know who really want to help the least developed countries, who want to make us a better world and who do not. You have guts to do it, don't you?
By the way, what is the most difficult obstacle you have had in this conference so far? Apart from shopping for Christmas gifts before you go, what other things would you like to do, and at the deepest in your heart, how do you want this conference to be ended?
Next time when I see you again in the HKCEC, I hope I will have the guts to give you a hug... if your security guard allows me to do so.
Good luck. Keep our fingers crossed. Make everyone's voice heard!
Best regards,
Gloria
Hong Kong |
Edited 12/17/2005 3:25 am by GloriaFong |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.9 in reply to 2120.1 | |
Wonderful efforts. I appreciate your concern and honest graceness towards smaller countries to sustain. God bless these efforts
Anand |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.10 in reply to 2120.1 | |
Cher Pascal Lamy
A quick word during this critical period of the Hong Kong Ministerial to say how interesting it has been for me, a former senior Trade official, to follow up your very busy schedule and multiple efforts to make this Ministerial sucessful. For me, it has been almost as I was still participating in one of the EC Delegations, while having the opportunity of learning, through your diary, first hand news about different events and meetings taking place that usually delegates may miss, being so focussed on the negotiations.
I only regret that the media in general prefer to draw a dark picture of the possible Conference's outcome rather than talk about the positive aspects of the Doha round - the focus on development and the initiatives announced since the beginning of this week -, while referring to demonstrations in the streets of Hong Kong and discontentment of several groups of interests. Clearly, the dialogue with civil society either at the WTO level, either at the EU and national level need to be better explained to the media all over the world.
Bon courage for the rest of the Conference: I am really confident that your work and negotiating skills will play a key role in bringing the Conference to a positive outcome.
Teresa Moreira
Ministry of Economy, Lisbon, Portugal
|
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.11 in reply to 2120.1 | |
Monsieur le Directeur général,
C'est tous les matins un grand plaisir de lire votre journal. Pour la première fois, nous, à Genève, avons vraiment le sentiment de faire partie de "l'équipe qui s'est déplacée". Je parle en mon nom, mais je suis sûre qu'on ne me contradira pas. Je vous souhaite bonne continuation - nous sommes de tout coeur avec vous pour que les négociations soient un succès.
Anne L. |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.12 in reply to 2120.1 | |
Dear Mr Lamy
I am always try to read the message of your's it really enlighted me about the hard work you do,
I strongly believe that you will look for balanced development of world & come up with some of the best Idea for over all development of the world & would not surrender in front of developed country ,
One thing I still cant undeerstand why developed country do not want other developing countries to come up
Hope fully you'll do the Justice to all, lot of acpectation is there on you from the world,
May God give you the strenth to do justice
Thank you
|
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.13 in reply to 2120.1 | |
|
2117.4 in reply to 2117.1 |
|
|
Cher Monsieur,
je suis un jeune journaliste espagnol qui vient de tomber sur votre journal de ces jours de réunion ministérielle et qui -honnêtement- hallucine avec le ton profond et humain de vos paroles. Je vous connais de peu de votre passage par la Commission Européenne), mais vous venez de gagner un adepte. Merci pour cet effort humble et direct de dédramatisation et descente à la rue pour parler la langue que nous parlons tous les jours chez nous.
Bien à vous,
Fernando Navarro. | |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.14 in reply to 2120.1 | |
Cher Pascal, Merci d'avoir trouvé le temps de regarder les cargos. Je ne sais pas encore si vous avez raison de faire ce que vous faites, mais la façon dont vous le faites me va. Courage. La question à la quelle les opposants au mouvement en cours se posent difficilement est celle des apports des échanges aux progrès social global. Quelle est la quantité de bonheur supplémentaire que les echanges amènent ? Est-ce un jeu gangnant/gagnant ? Qui sont les perdants et qui soint les gagnants ? |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.15 in reply to 2120.2 | |
You are certainly right that the obstacles are many and formidable. But we must believe that changes for the better can be made, and that they can achieve at least a modest increase in the stock of fairness and justice in the world.
PL |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.16 in reply to 2120.3 | |
Seattle certainly left a bad taste and a sad image in many people's minds, with discord inside and outside the conference rooms. But in a sense Seattle was the turning point when many members of the WTO realized they were not only along for the ride that they could take the wheel. The emergence of developing countries as a force within the WTO, not only as a majority of Members, but as full partners in steering the course, is what stands out during the years since Seattle. By the way, I do make mistakes from time to time. But I try to learn from them.
PL |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.17 in reply to 2120.4 | |
Thank you for those thoughtful words and believe me I take them to heart in considering how we can make the WTO not only more effective in contributing to global economic development, but also how we can earn the support of more people like you. Any ideas in that respect would be welcome. By the way, I do not "represent" France. France as a member of the EU is represented as such in the WTO. But, true, I am French and grateful to my country for having educated me as a public servant.
PL |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.18 in reply to 2120.5 | |
Nei Hau and thank you for these good wishes.
PL |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.19 in reply to 2120.6 | |
Thank you for your encouragement. It is something I and the WTO need more of.
PL |
| |
|
| | | | | 2120.20 in reply to 2120.7 | |
We certainly need to have espérance jump very high and often if we are to reach our objective of concluding the Doha Round before the end of the year. Thank you.
PL |
| |
|
| Navigate this discussion:
1-20 21-27 |
|
|
|
| Is this too complicated? Switch to Basic View |
|