Message Boards

  • Welcome Guest
icenetwork.com Forum
  • To: All
  • 10/20/12
  • kana
  • From: kana
  • Posts: 5

I would like to ask ice network to consider providing subscribers the option of hearing the skater's music uninterrupted by commentary. Being able to hear the skater's music uninterrupted by commentary is one of the reasons I renewed my subscription to ice network.

True, some portion of Nationals broadcast has had commentary, but unless I am misreading the recent release about Sectionals having a sports desk, it appears that this year Sectionals will have commentary as well.

I am pleased to hear that icenetwork will be offering live coverage of the 3 sectionals from the 2012-2013 qualifying season, but my excitement will be nullified if it means every time I return to ice network to view the on demand video, I have to listen to commentary, and hear the skater's performance being dissected jump by jump.

I understand that skating has largely disappeared from TV in the US, and ice network may be trying to fill the broadcasting void, but for me, this would be a disincentive to continue patronizing ice network.

I know that I am not alone in wishing to hear the skater's music uninterrupted. For those of us who prefer our skating without commentary, the erudition and charm of the commentator does not matter. What the commentator adds is never entirely unbiased, and while it may enhance the athletic competition aspects and make some viewers nostalgic for #### Button, it makes the performance less pleasant to re-visit.

If expert commentators want to share their insights, I would appreciate it if they could do so after the skater has finished and is taking his or her bow.

Thank you.


Edited 10/20/12   by  kana
Edited 10/20/12   by  kana
  • To: All
  • 10/21/12
  • emma
  • From: emma
  • Posts: 4
Please keep the commentary.
  • 10/21/12

 One must buy a ticket and view live in person to escape the commentary. Sad to see all the empty seats today even with modest ticket prices $15 to $40. Eurosport broadcast typically had the most quiet, sparse and unobtrusive commentary. Waiting to see how Universal Sports handles this starting with Skate Canada. The old ABC coverage was very good in spite of all the talking especially with human interest and behind the scenes. My biggest televised thrill still 1999 Grand Prix Superfinal Irina vs. Michelle.

  • To: All
  • 10/21/12
  • kbjh
  • From: kbjh
  • Posts: 2
please keep commentary
  • 10/22/12
Icenetwork/MLB is doing really well to offer both the event broadcast and the "b" or backstage broadcast.  Attempting to offer two different audio tracks would probably require a higher subscription cost to increase the bandwidth for the additional audio channel. 

I think Tonia does a great job! 
  • 10/22/12
Speaking just for myself - I'm totally with you on that one. I watch the videos over and over again throughout the year - I'd SO much rather just listen to the skaters' music and watch the performance. I do understand that other people enjoy the commentary and like to have to moves explained. So maybe there could be a compromise and the commentator could limit her remarks just to the skating that's actually happening? I found there was an awful lot of 'background talk' on the skaters, and comments on how early in the season it is - all that could definitely be left until after the performance. I hope everyone's wishes can be at least partially met with this - but I did find the commentary on Skate America just a bit too intrusive.
  • 10/24/12
Tonia is annoying. She just has to keep talking and tell us why so and so missed a jump. We saw it with our own eyes we don't need her to tell us every little thing that's going on.
  ©   Prospero Technologies LLC.   All Rights Reserved.