Click here to return to homepage         Search the WTO site       Guide to using this site, site map       Register to receive info on updates by email       How to contact the WTO
 
About the institution. Read and download introductions to the WTO. Vacancies. Etc  |  Find out what’s been happening in the WTO  |  Trade in goods (tariffs, agriculture, textiles, anti-dumping, etc), services, intellectual property. Disputes. Development. Environment. Regionalism. Government procurement. Etc.  |  Legal texts, analysis, statistics, publications, services for media and NGOs, downloads, links, etc  |  Find and download official documents  |  Chat about WTO issues, participate in forums

español     français

Message Board:
Read and Post!
    Chat:
Type or Talk Live!
Signed in as: Guest
Login

The WTO after ten years

 General (Read-Only Folder) -  Trade liberlisation and the poornotify me whenever anyone posts in this discussionSubscribe  
 
From: JohnMadeley  4/21/2005 10:28 am 
To: ALL  (1 of 3) 
 14.1 

Dear forum,

The WTO would improve its standing and increase its credibility if it presented a more balanced view of the effects of trade liberalisation on the poor.

The WTO too often gives the impression that it is barely aware of, or even trying to hide, the many studies - from both official and NGO sources - which show the damaging impact of trade liberalisation on the poor. For compilations of studies, see for example:

Trade and hunger - an overview of case studies on the impact of trade liberalisation on food security, Forum Syd,
http://www.forumsyd.se/globala.htm

The impact of trade liberalisation on food security in the South, Literature review, CIDSE,
http://www.cidse.org

Secondly, when the WTO speaks of benefits for the poor from trade, it would do well to disaggregate more. The WTO should estimate how much of the benefit from additional trade from liberalisation will accrue to the traders, transnational corporations for example, and how much to the poor. Unless the WTO shows more awareness that it is companies not the poor who trade on world markets, it is unconvincing in its attempts to claim that the poor will gain. It gives the irmpression of not dealing with the real world.

As an organisation that deals with trade, the WTO needs to say more about the activity of the traders.

John Madeley, (writer author of:
A People's World: Alternatives to economic globalization.
Hungry for Trade: how the poor pay for free trade.
Big Business, Poor Peoples: the impact of transnational corporations on the world's poor.

 
   Options
 
  

 
From: GeoffEdward2  4/23/2005 3:24 am 
To: JohnMadeley  (2 of 3) 
 14.2 in reply to 14.1 

John

 

For years trade enthusiasts have been blind to the kind of evidence you have mentioned about the suffering of the poor. Who needs evidence if following textbook theory?

 

Regards

 

Geoff Edwards

 
   Options
 
  

 
From: JohnMadeley  4/27/2005 10:56 am 
To: JohnMadeley  (3 of 3) 
 14.3 in reply to 14.1 

Geoff

It's tragic the way the evidence on trade liberalisation is being ignored. I had always understood that theory was built up from empirical evidence. Please WTO and academics - go the poor and revise your theory - urgenly!

John Madeley

 
   Options
 
  

Rate My Interest:
   
Adjust text size:
Is this too complicated? Switch to Basic View