TwinCities.com home page TwinCities.com home page TwinCities.com news page TwinCities.com sports page Twincities.com business page TwinCities.com entertainment page TwinCities.com life & culture page TwinCities.com travel page Subscribe to the Pioneer Press TwinCities.com classifieds TwinCities.com jobs TwinCities.com cars TwinCities.com homes and real estate TwinCities.com Shop Local
Welcome:
Guest
Signed in as: Guest
Login

Related Forums:
Pioneer Press Treasure Hunt
Business
News
Sports
Back To Discussion List
Quick Vote

 General -  Culpepper Tradenotify me whenever anyone posts in this discussionSubscribe  
 
From: WilburVO5  3/19/2006 10:50 am 
To: ALL  (1 of 6) 
 324.1 

I agree with the Culpepper trade...here's why:

When a quarterback suffers such a terrible injury to the knee where it is going to prohibit him or have him "second guess" if he should run...a valuable dimension of his skills ARE LOST and how defenses will now prepare for Culpepper will be different.  HE WILL NOT HAVE THE ABILITY TO RUN LIKE HE DID BEFORE.  Defenses will go for his knees.

He is not the same Pro Bowl QB of before.  Therefore, a second round pick is what the NFL market perceives as his value.  We are lucky to get a second round pick!!!  HE WILL NOT BE THE SAME QB.  For example, Tommy Kramer after the Tampa Bay Buc's gave him a season ending injury.  Remember that one?

Think about it.  The Dolphins and the Vikings made a fair deal.

Any thoughts?

 
   Options Reply
4.0 (1 vote)
 
  

 
From: VikingMoose  3/19/2006 9:11 pm 
To: WilburVO5  (2 of 6) 
 324.2 in reply to 324.1 

All I have to say...

Culpepper hasn't done anything for the Vikings yet.  How many times has he made it to the playoffs?  Look at last year, the year before!  Culpepper isn't worth the number on his jersey!  Draft a quarterback in the second round.  Nothing to lose.  What round was Brad Johnson?  Oh, that's right!  He won a Super Bowl.

Viking Moose

 
   Options Reply
4.0 (1 vote)
 
  

 
From: Guest 3/23/2006 7:33 pm 
To: VikingMoose unread  (3 of 6) 
 324.3 in reply to 324.2 

Are you trying to say that Brad Johnson would have won a Super Bowl with our sorry ass defense that Culpepper had to QB with???

Did you go to the Cleveland game and see how a former Super Bowl QB looked with a poor defense??

Did you watch the Giants game in which Johnson kept the Giants in the game by continually squandering scoring opportunities??

Did Johnson throw the Chicago game by blowing hold after hold on field goals???

 

Coach Healy

 
   Options Reply
 
  

 
From: drkevorkian  3/26/2006 2:58 am 
To: ALL  (4 of 6) 
 324.4 in reply to 324.1 

What's the heaviest thing the O line had to lift last year? Daunte.

He will do less for Miami than Randy did for the Raiders—and that wasn't much. I got good and tired of watching him impersonate Michael Jordan and dribble the ball down the field, usually to the other guys, and lots of those happened when there was nobody around and nothing but open field in front of him.

Vikes will be a LOT better without him or the bad vibe he would have brought with him if he had stayed.

 
   Options Reply
 
  

 
From: Guest 3/26/2006 11:21 pm 
To: drkevorkian  (5 of 6) 
 324.5 in reply to 324.4 

Did you see an offensive line??? What games were you watching it must have been the last half of the season when the special teams and defense stepped up!!

That Giant game was one for the ages!!!

I know that the Bears, Lions and Packers agree with you about being happy that Daunte left.

 
   Options Reply
 
  

 
From: drkevorkian  3/27/2006 1:07 am 
To: Guest  (6 of 6) 
 324.6 in reply to 324.5 

I'm sorry, I probably wasn't clear. I was talking about his ENTIRE TENURE with the team, not just last year. And you're right: that 41-doughut game in the Meadowlands was timeless, especially when you look at the horses he had around him for an O line, Korey, Steussie plus Robert Smith to take the heat off. There's a lot more to QB-ing than throwing brain dead heavers and letting Randy run under them making circus catches—as we all found out decisively at 2-5.

As for the other teams in the division, seems like we've been looking up at the leaders more than we haven't. If they're thanking their lucky stars, my money's still riding on the Vikes now that they're un-Daunte'd. (Ouch, I know, I couldn't resist)

 
   Options Reply
 
  

Rate My Interest:
   
Adjust text size:
Is this too complicated? Switch to Basic View



Although we do not have any obligation to monitor this board, we reserve the right at all times to check this board and to remove any information or materials that are unlawful, threatening, abusive, libelous, defamatory, obscene, vulgar, pornographic, profane, indecent or otherwise objectionable to us in our sole discretion and to disclose any information necessary to satisfy the law, regulation, or government request. We also reserve the right to permanently block any user who violates these terms and conditions. All threats to systems or site infrastructure shall be assumed genuine in nature and will be reported to the appropriate law enforcement authorities.

© Copyright 2007 MediaNews Group. All Rights Reserved. Any copying, redistribution or retransmission of any of the contents of this service without the express written consent of The McClatchy Company, LLC. is expressly prohibited.